A great spot to sit and chat with locals. The owner is always helpful and accommodating. My favorite things to get here are the burgers and the house salad with grilled chicken. It's a small place and can get crowded at peak times but it's worth the wait!

Absolute best spot to eat in Newburgh/Boonville area. Great family owned restaurant where no one is a stranger. Fantastic Old Fashioned and other cocktails. Don't sleep on Commanders!

Burgers are 10/10, the salads are to so good, staff is always so nice! Nice and home felt environment good lighting. I would highly recommend Commanders Grill to anyone and everyone

Food was great but the service was a little slow. The decor was homie and pleasant. Definitely looking forward to going back another time.

The food, service, and ambiance were all amazing! My very hard to impress 7 year old said this was the best grilled cheese he's ever had.

We were heading home from Evansville and picked Booneville. There were a few places on the square. I happened to find parking at Commanders so we picked them. What a great choice! We sat at the bar and I asked the bartender what he recommended. He said the cheesesteak and burgers. That's what we ordered. No regrets. Absolutely delicious. It looks high end on the inside but not that way at all. Very comfortable. Engaging bartender. Check them out.

A small hometown dinner that is right on the boonville square. The Commander Burger was amazing (5-5). It usually comes with chips but I upgraded to fries. That was a mistake. The fries were old/hard/slightly cold (0/5). My wife got a burger with the chips. The house chips were great (4/5) Our server was on top of it. When a drink is brought out before you ask for a refill is (5/5) Will go back again to try different dishes

Love this place and service! Tried their steak- so gooooood!!! It's a different type of mood too a little darker in there but I liked it, felt homey!

We dined here about a week ago. The fried chicken was delicious & juicy. Can't wait to go again.

If you love good food and history, this place will not disappoint. What an awesome find while road tripping one evening! As far as good, the Indiana Tenderloin sandwich is a treat. A huge pork tenderloin on a nice hoagie bun and all the fixin's tasted wonderful. It practically melted in my mouth and was so flavorful. The blueberry cheesecake was one of the best cheesecakes I have ever tasted and is made from scratch from the owner's family friend. Service was great and staff was amazing. Saw a local coming in and the bartender motioned to them and began their drink if choice from memory. It reminded me of the Cheers theme song about a place where "everyone knows your name." The atmosphere was of people who seemed to be close friends and neighbors and treated us as new friends when we walked in. The namesake of the restaurant and uncle of the owner (and Boonsville native) is the late U.S. Navy Captain Ralph Weyerbacher, the father of the navy's rigid airships created and utilized shortly after WWI. He created them from memory after studying the German Zeppelin. He commanded the USS SHENANDOAH (ZR 1) which was the flagship for the prototypes made for the Navy. Although they were never really utilized in warfare, it was a forerunner of the modern-day Naval Aviation. Being retired Navy, this was a particularly memorable experience. It was enjoyable to see the pride this community takes in its native children. Ee thoroughly enjoyed this restaurant and will definitely find a reason to make the trip back to Boonville to eat here again! You MUST come in and enjoy a moment in your day with these great folks in a great community. We loved it here.